xanax vs. valium

18 replies [Last post]
libbylib
User offline. Last seen 4 years 48 weeks ago. Offline
Member
Joined: Jun 4 2007
Posts: 4

I have taken valium for flying anxiety. A new doctor wants me to try xanax. What doage of xanax is the equivalent of 5 mg valium?

kirby
kirby's picture
User offline. Last seen 3 hours 37 min ago. Offline
Moderator
Joined: Dec 26 2004
Posts: 4698
Xanax Versus Valium

According to the Benzodiazepine Equivalent Chart at benzo.org.uk, 0.25 mg Xanax equals 5 mg Valium.


I'm not a pharmacist or a medical doctor. This message is not medical advice nor is it an offer to provide medical advice. All drug identifications should be validated by a licensed MD or pharmacist.
RxHistory
User offline. Last seen 4 years 46 weeks ago. Offline
Member
Joined: Jun 4 2007
Posts: 7
From my DOCS point of view.

Valium is almost four time less potent than XANAX.  The major difference being the incredible short half life of xanax. 

Also so far as other benzos go, I'v been told that roughly 1.5mg of Klonopin=2mg Xanax, 1mg Ativan=2mg xanax and 40mg Valium=2mg xanax. 

___________________________________________________________________

RxHistory: Whats Up, don't take any sarcasm seriously please.

jb24
User offline. Last seen 4 years 45 weeks ago. Offline
Member
Joined: May 16 2007
Posts: 13
Try this.

I get 10 mg Valium prescribed for anxiety and panic attacks only. To me, they seem to work better than a Xanax unless it is a Xanax Bar which is 2mg. I don't know the dosage of a .5 Xanax but Valium to me is better if I had to choose. Also another even better anxiety drug is Klonopin. They have helped me alot more than either Valium or Xanax. Even the strongest doses of the others. So if you really have the anxiety ask about Klonopin at your next doctor visit. You may not like it , but to me it is the best all around.

libbylib
User offline. Last seen 4 years 48 weeks ago. Offline
Member
Joined: Jun 4 2007
Posts: 4
thanks

Thank you to all who answered. It was really helpful.

JeckPDX
User offline. Last seen 10 weeks 6 days ago. Offline
Member
Joined: Oct 5 2005
Posts: 226
I agree that  Kolonpin

I agree that  Kolonpin works the bst for me too, but I take valium for a muscle relaxant as well as for nerves. I don't agree with the equivalent dosages posted above. I would say .5mg xanax is about equal to 7.5 - 10mg valium. I also dont like the "floored" feeling that I get from xanax and valium makes me a more happier camper. I also dont like how xanax has this huge peak and then its just gone leaving you feeling like &*&?, while valium leaves your body much more slowly making the come down much less noticeable. Xanax has also been proven to be more addicting. Temazpeam (restoril) also works great for me. Especially for long flights. Its a bit more sedating than others an is meant mostly for insomnia but works great for generalized anxiety and has a short half life with no nasty come off effects like with xanax. In the end, its up to you but my policy has always been to take what I know works well and has been efective in the past as opposed to trying something new and not nkowing how I will react. Or ask to try the xanax is your doc prefer you do so and ask for an rx for valium also in case you dont react well to the xanax. Im not sure if your dr. will be willing to do thgis but

I have an axcellent rapport with my pcp and we have an great decision making relationship where we are both involved and he pretty much lets me choose the med giving me the risks vs. benefits as long as they are appropriate for my condition. Best of luck but if it is between .5mg xanax and valium, I would try fopr a 10mg valium, or at least 5mg with instructoin to take 1-2 tabs.

PDX

Dr. Lois
User offline. Last seen 50 weeks 5 days ago. Offline
Member
Joined: Apr 12 2007
Posts: 1207
Twelve hour flight, take

Twelve hour flight, take Klonapin.

Four hour flight, take Xanax.

 

libbylib
User offline. Last seen 4 years 48 weeks ago. Offline
Member
Joined: Jun 4 2007
Posts: 4
when to take pill

One more question...

I need to take the Valium about two hours before my flight so it is working at the right time.

Is it the same with Xanax? Or does Xanax begin to work faster? How long before it is effective?

What about Klonapin?

Thank you

SoloCPhT
User offline. Last seen 29 weeks 6 days ago. Offline
Member
Joined: Oct 6 2005
Posts: 2232
With my experience with

With my experience with anxiety and panic attacks, Ive taken Xanax,Valium,Ativan,BuSpar,Klonopin and currently take Restoril for sleep. Xanax does seem to work much faster than Valium within an hour but doesnt last as long, Ativan works even faster within about 15-30 minutes. There are also Sublingual Tablets that disolve under your tongue, and those ones work extremely fast 10-20 minutes for the Ativan for me. Klonopin also works faster than Valium and the effects are more mellow and less sedating, but the anti-anxiety effects are far superior and all together the feeling while on it feels "cleaner". It seems though that Klonopin is getting more attention on the streets lately, so you might want to be careful about asking for it, unless you have a good relationship with your Doc. Hope my rambling makes sense and helps.

libbylib
User offline. Last seen 4 years 48 weeks ago. Offline
Member
Joined: Jun 4 2007
Posts: 4
xanax

thank you--I guess I will try .25 of xanax an hour before my next flight!

MBH
User offline. Last seen 22 weeks 6 days ago. Offline
Member
Joined: Nov 30 2011
Posts: 2
Just my 2 Cents worth

Just another post that confirms how differently every individual reacts to medications! Klonopin does nothing for my anxiety or my Panic disorder, it doesnt even take away the bad thoughts that come in my head(the worries). Xanax is far cleaner than Klonopin, in and out the body in one day, I think you are referring to your memory not being affected by the Klonopin as it is with the Xanax, which you describe as "cleaner"? It certainly leaves MUCH residue in comparison to xanax, and it is toxic to the liver.

Its incredible the number of people that "prefer" Clonazepam for their "Anxiety Disorders" and their "Panic Disorders". To me, Klonopin is a pill that I take 1mg(made by roche), my stomach starts to cringe, does nothing for my anxiety, does even less for my panic, and all it does it leave me dozed out of it for days, until the withdrawal comes, then I hyperventilate for days before by body rids itself of that nasty dirty drug. There are many references online which will also confirm that Clonazepam along with Triazolam are the benzos with the highest incidence of side effects and the worst tolerated of all benzos. Clonazepam is also toxic to the liver(Doctors never tell you this), which having a liver/blood disorder, I think is the reason it does not work for my panic nor my anxiety. It is the most addictive benzo I have ever been on. Clonazepam is solely approved as an anti-epileptic around the rest of the world. Read up!--

http://www.benzosupport.org/valium_verus_klonopin.htm

And Xanax hands down is way better for anxiety. Ive never had a problem with abuse nor tolerance. It is addictive and should be handled carefully, but Klonopin is CRAAP in my book. Does nothing to me other than make me a zombie. Plus after it is metabolized after 6-8 hours, its converted into an INACTIVE METABOLITE that stays in your body for up to a week after one dose. I dont have seizures. Why would I take a seizure medicine? Not going in my body!

Xanax- made for panic. Those who can't handle its effects, choose klonopin because they have their "memory intact". Well personally, I like having a clear mind, no bad thoughts coming into it. But thats me..

For a long acting benzo, Valium is king. Has been for decades. 4x the half life and much better effects, no withdrawal if you do it the right way. and I have been on almost every benzo that they make for my panic disorder.

The regimen is as follows for now, 40mg Valium, 6mg Xanax (+2mg PRN), .5mg Klonopin x2 as needed, Restoril 30mg for sleep. (as far as anxiety meds goes!)